Haemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis both remove waste and extra fluid when your kidneys can no longer remove enough. Haemodialysis filters your blood through a machine, while peritoneal dialysis uses the lining inside your abdomen as a filter. They also differ in treatment schedules, access procedures, infection risks and what you need to do each day.
How does each type of dialysis work?
During haemodialysis, your blood flows through tubing to a dialyser, a filter outside your body. Waste and extra fluid pass across a thin membrane into dialysis fluid, and the filtered blood returns to your body. Your blood and the dialysis fluid normally remain separate.
Peritoneal dialysis uses your peritoneum, the membrane lining your abdominal cavity, as the filter. Dialysis fluid enters your abdomen through a soft tube called a catheter, stays there for a prescribed time called a dwell, and then drains out with waste and extra water. This fill, dwell and drain process is called an exchange, as explained by the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases.
Neither method replaces every function of healthy kidneys or cures kidney failure. You'll still need regular blood tests, any prescribed medicines and treatment for problems such as anaemia, changes in blood pressure and mineral imbalances.
What access procedure will you need?
For haemodialysis, you need reliable access to your bloodstream. An arteriovenous fistula joins an artery to a vein, usually in your arm. Another option is a graft, which connects them using an artificial tube. You'll need a procedure to create either type of access and time before you can use it safely.
You may need a dialysis catheter in a large vein if you must start treatment urgently or other types of access aren't suitable. Catheters generally carry a higher risk of bloodstream infection than a fistula. Your nephrologist and vascular access surgeon will recommend an option based on your blood vessels, health and expected treatment needs.
For peritoneal dialysis, you'll need a procedure to place a catheter through your abdominal wall. Your team will usually allow time for it to heal before routine use, although you may be able to start earlier under a supervised urgent-start programme if you're suitable. You or a trained caregiver must learn how to connect the equipment, perform exchanges and care for the catheter exit site.
How do dialysis schedules differ?
With centre-based haemodialysis, you'll commonly have three sessions each week, each lasting around four hours. Your prescription may differ depending on your remaining kidney function, fluid gain, body size and blood test results. You'll also need time for travel, waiting and recovery. Home haemodialysis is another option where suitable training and support are available, and schedules can vary.
You'll usually need peritoneal dialysis every day. With continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis, or CAPD, you perform manual exchanges throughout the day, often about four. Automated peritoneal dialysis, or APD, uses a machine called a cycler to perform exchanges mainly while you sleep. You may also need a daytime dwell or exchange.
With centre-based treatment, staff carry out the procedure and monitor you during each session. At home, you take greater responsibility for treatment, managing supplies and recognising problems. Peritoneal dialysis may give you more control over your timetable, but it doesn't mean fewer treatment days.
What are the main risks of each type?
During haemodialysis, you may experience low blood pressure, cramps, nausea or tiredness, particularly if you need to have fluid removed quickly. Your dialysis access can become infected, narrow or develop a blood clot. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases lists low blood pressure and muscle cramps among recognised treatment problems.
With peritoneal dialysis, you may develop peritonitis, an infection inside your abdomen, or an infection around the catheter exit site. Other possible problems include hernias, fluid leaks and weight gain as your body absorbs glucose from dialysis fluid. You can reduce your infection risk by cleaning your hands carefully and following the connection technique your team teaches you.
- Contact your dialysis team immediately if you notice cloudy drained fluid, new abdominal pain or fever during peritoneal dialysis.
- Report redness, swelling, discharge or increasing pain around any dialysis access promptly.
- Tell your team immediately if the usual buzzing sensation in your fistula disappears.
- Seek emergency care for severe breathlessness, chest pain, confusion or uncontrolled bleeding from your access.
How will dialysis affect your daily life?
Your food and fluid allowances depend on your blood test results, urine output and dialysis prescription, not just the method you use. With centre-based haemodialysis, you'll often need to control your fluid intake more closely between sessions. Daily peritoneal dialysis may give you more flexibility, but excess salt and fluid can still cause swelling and high blood pressure.
You may need more protein with either treatment, and you also lose protein in the fluid drained during peritoneal dialysis. Ask a renal dietitian to set your protein, potassium, phosphate and fluid targets. Don't copy another patient's diet or use herbal remedies, supplements or salt substitutes without checking with your team.
Think about how fixed centre appointments, daily home procedures or overnight machine use would fit around your work or studies. For peritoneal dialysis, you'll need a clean space to connect the equipment and plenty of storage space for supplies. Before travelling with either method, you'll need to plan for treatment availability, equipment, supplies and medical support.
Which type of dialysis may suit you?
Neither method is best for everyone. Your nephrologist should discuss which options are medically suitable and what you can realistically manage at home. Your age alone doesn't determine the choice, and previous abdominal surgery doesn't automatically rule out peritoneal dialysis.
- Discuss your heart health, abdominal conditions, blood vessels and remaining kidney function.
- Consider your eyesight, hand strength, mobility and ability to follow treatment steps.
- Check whether you have suitable space at home, reliable supplies and caregiver support if you need it.
- Ask how treatment will fit around your work, sleep, travel and transport arrangements.
- Review the full costs, including consumables, medicines, tests and travel, along with any available financial cover.
You can change methods if complications develop, dialysis no longer meets your needs or your circumstances change. You'll need to plan a switch because the new method requires suitable access and training. Discuss your preferences with your kidney care team early, including whether kidney transplantation is an option for you, rather than waiting until you need dialysis urgently.
Sources
- Peritoneal Dialysis · NIDDK (niddk.nih.gov)
- Hemodialysis · NIDDK (niddk.nih.gov)